II: Attitudes towards Education and Assessment of Schools Today
In general, Latinos, especially the foreign born, are more positive about public schools and more optimistic that schools are improving than either whites or African Americans. Latinos are also upbeat about their dealings with teachers and school administrators. However, a sizeable minority of Latinos takes a negative view of the state of public education. Although there is no strong consensus on the most important problems facing the schools, Latinos are most likely to cite security issues such as violence and drugs, while whites focus on funding issues and African Americans cite a wide range of concerns.
The vast majority of Latinos, whites and African Americans place a high value on a college education. While costs of education is named most often by all groups, Latinos, especially the foreign born, are more likely than whites and African Americans to say that discrimination and the desirability of staying close to family are major reasons why young people fail to finish college.
Latinos, whites and African Americans are nearly unanimous in wanting the schools to teach English to children who are immigrants or the children of immigrants. But, Latinos, especially the foreign-born, also want the schools to help such students maintain their native language while fewer – but still a majority – of whites agree. Only foreign-born Latinos believe the schools are currently doing a good job of teaching English to children from immigrant households, and both whites and African-Americans say that a poor mastery of English is an important factor in educational achievement problems for Latinos.
Ratings of Public Schools
Latinos, especially the foreign born, give good ratings to public schools. However, there is a sizeable minority that would give public schools an average or below average rating. (chart 1)
- When asked to give public schools the sort of letter grades that students generally receive, most Latinos would give the public schools in their community (63%) and nationwide (52%) an ‘A’ or ‘B.’
- Fewer Latinos, but still about three in ten, would give the schools in their community (29%) and nationwide (38%) a ‘C’, ‘D’, or ‘F.’
- Foreign-born Latinos are notably positive about the public schools, being considerably more likely to give a grade of ‘A’ to the schools in their community (33%) and to schools nationwide (22%) compared to native-born Latinos (16% and 7%).
Whites and African Americans are more negative about public schools than Latinos and are less likely to give public schools good ratings. Of the three groups, African Americans are the least positive about the schools in their communities, while whites give schools nationwide the lowest rating. (chart 1)
- Whites (26%) and African Americans (36%) are much less willing than Latinos (52%) to give an ‘A’ or ‘B’ to public schools nationwide.
- Whites are only slightly less likely than Latinos to give the public schools in their communities an ‘A’ or ‘B’ (58% vs. 63%). However, less than half of African Americans are willing to give the schools in their communities these grades (48%).
Most Latinos say that schools are either getting better or are staying about the same, however, a small minority feels the schools are getting worse. (chart 2)
- Nearly half (45%) of Latinos feel that schools have improved in the past five years, and foreign-born Latinos (50%) are more positive than native-born Latinos (39%). Meanwhile, 29% of all Latinos say that schools have stayed about the same and 21% say they have gotten worse.
Whites and African Americans are less optimistic than Latinos about the progress that is being made in schools. (chart 2)
- Far fewer whites (25%) and African Americans (31%) say that schools have improved in the last five years, compared to Latinos (45%).
- Whites (30%) and African Americans (35%) are more likely than Latinos (21%) to say that schools have gotten worse.
Security issues such as drugs, violence and gang activity are cited most often by Latinos as the most important problems facing their community schools. (chart 3)
- About one in four (24%) Latinos (29% of the foreign born, 18% of the native born) report the most important problem facing their community schools is a security issue, such as gangs, violence or drugs.
- However, 15% of all Latinos say that the most important problem in their community schools is a problem with teachers, 10% say it is a funding problem, 9% say it is a problem with the children in the schools, and 7% say it is a problem with the curriculum.
Lack of adequate funding is cited most often by whites as the most important problem facing their community schools, while African Americans cite several problems— security issues, funding shortfalls, teacher quality, undisciplined children—in almost equal measure. (chart 3)
- Nearly one in four (24%) whites say that the most important problem facing their community schools is a problem with funding, compared to 10% of Latinos.
- Conversely, 11% of whites say that the most important problem facing their community schools is a security issue, compared to 24% of Latinos.
- African Americans give about the same importance to security issues (17%), funding (16%), children’s attitudes and behavior (15%), and the quality of teachers and teaching (14%).
Most Latinos say that the schools attended by primarily Latino children are comparable to those attended by primarily white or African American children. However, a sizable portion says that schools attended primarily by Latinos and those attended primarily by African Americans are worse than those schools attended primarily by whites.
- Latinos (53%) are more likely to say that schools attended primarily by Latinos are comparable to those attended by primarily whites than to say either that they are worse (28%) or better (13%).
- However, even more Latinos (71%) say that schools attended primarily by Latinos are comparable to those attended by primarily African Americans. Few Latinos say either that such schools are worse (9%) or better (14%) than those schools attended primarily by African Americans.
African Americans are more likely than Latinos to say that whites attend better schools.
- Nearly half of African Americans (46%) say that schools attended primarily by African Americans are worse than those attended by whites, while 38% say they are comparable and 10% say they are better.
- More than a third of African Americans (36%) say that schools attended by Latinos are worse than those attended by whites, but more (45%) say they are comparable (7% say they are better).
- African Americans see little differences between schools attended primarily by Latinos and those attended primarily by African Americans. Three-quarters of African Americans (77%) say these schools are about the same, while only 9% say schools attended by primarily by Latinos are better and 8% say they are worse than those attended primarily by African Americans.
Nearly half of whites say that schools attended primarily by Latinos and African Americans are comparable to schools attended primarily by whites.
- Whites (46%) are more likely to say that schools attended primarily by Latinos are comparable to those attended by primarily whites than to say either that they are worse (27%) or better (6%).
- Whites (45%) are also slightly more likely to say that schools attended primarily by African Americans are comparable to those attended by primarily whites than to say either that they are worse (38%) or better (5%).
- Even more whites (62%) say that schools attended primarily by Latinos are comparable to those attended by primarily African Americans. Few whites say either that such schools are worse (7%) or better (12%) than those schools attended primarily by African Americans.
Parent’s Experiences and Involvement with Their Child’s School
Most Latino parents who have a child in kindergarten through the 12th grade report positive views of their children’s teachers and the experiences they have had with school officials. (chart 4)
- Most Latino parents say that their child’s teachers have a good understanding of their child’s academic strengths and weaknesses (80%) and overall development and happiness (76%).
- Parents are positive about the experiences that they have had with school officials—53% of Latino parents say it was a “very good” experience and 37% say it was a “somewhat good” experience.
- Whites and African Americans largely share these positive views with Latinos although African Americans are somewhat less enthusiastic with 39% saying they have had “very good” experiences with school officials compared to 49% of whites.
Most Spanish-dominant Latino parents report that schools tend to be accommodating in communicating with them in Spanish about their child’s performance. However, there is still a large portion that cannot get report cards or standardized test scores in Spanish. (chart 5)
- Most Latino parents whose primary language is Spanish and who have limited proficiency with English report that they can get report cards (72%) and standardized test scores (66%) in Spanish. Even more report being able to talk to a school official in Spanish to discuss their child’s performance (87%) or get a teacher that can speak Spanish with them (84%).
Most parents—Latinos, whites and African Americans alike— say that they have a lot of influence over their child’s education. (chart 6)
- The vast majority of Latino parents (79%) feel that they have “a lot” of influence over their child’s education and there is no difference between the native and foreign born on this score. A similar share of African Americans express this view (76%) while somewhat fewer whites (61%) say they have “a lot” of influence.
Foreign-born Latinos are less likely than other parents to say that they know a lot about the curriculum and academic goals in their child’s grade. (chart 7)
- About two-thirds of native-born Latino (66%), white (67%) and African American (68%) parents say that they know “a lot” about the curriculum and academic goals of their child’s grade. Less than half (43%) of foreign-born Latino parents express the same view.
In general, Latino parents are actively involved in their child’s education. Most say that they take part in activities at their child’s school and typically help their child with homework. A significant portion also reports meeting with their child’s teacher regularly. (charts 8, 9, 10)
- The majority of Latinos say that they have attended a PTA meeting (74%), participated in a fundraiser (63%), or volunteered (55%) at their child’s school.
- Foreign-born parents are less likely than native-born parents to report participating in a fundraiser (57% vs. 75%) or volunteering (47% vs. 71%) at their child’s school, but they are more likely to report having attended a PTA meeting (77% vs. 67%).
- Latino parents say that they help their children with their homework often—59% say they help their child nearly every day and 28% say they help once or twice a week.
- Latino parents report that they meet with their child’s teachers often—42% say they meet with them once a month and 44% say they meet with them a few times a year.
Although white parents also say that they are active at their child’s school, they are likely to report helping their child with their homework and meeting with their teacher less often than Latino or African American parents. (charts 8, 9, 10)
- White (72%) and African American (64%) parents are more likely than Latino (55%) parents to say that they have volunteered at their child’s school. White (75%) and African American (71%) parents are also more likely than Latino (63%) parents to say that they have participated in a fundraising activity at their child’s school.
- White parents are less likely to report that they have attended a PTA meeting at their child’s school (59%), compared to Latino (74%) and African American (71%) parents.
- White parents report helping their children with their homework less often than Latino and African American parents. Almost half (48%) of white parents say that they help their children with their homework nearly every day, compared to about six in ten Latino (59%) and African American (61%) parents.
- White parents report meeting with their child’s teacher less often than Latino and African American parents. Less than three in ten (27%) white parents say they meet with their child’s teacher about once a month, compared to 42% of Latino parents and 46% of African American parents.
Perceived Reasons Latino Students are not Doing as Well as their White Peers
Latinos do not focus on any single reason why Latino children are not doing as well academically as their white peers. Many Latinos say that schools, teachers, parents, and the students themselves are all part of the problem. (chart 11)
- Latinos say that major reasons Latino students do not perform as well as their white peers include:
- Too many Latino parents neglect to push their kids to work hard (53% say this is a major reason).
- The school is often too quick to label Latino kids as having behavior or learning problems (51%).
- Too many white teachers do not know how to deal with Latino kids because they come from different cultures (47%).
- Latino students have weaker English language skills than white students (47%).
- Schools that have mostly Latino students have fewer good teachers (44%).
- Because of racial stereotypes, teachers and principals have lower expectations for Latino students (43%).
Whites and African Americans are most likely to identify weaker English language skills as a major reason behind poor Latino academic performance. (chart 11)
- Nearly six in ten whites (58%) and African Americans (59%) say that a major reason that Latino students are not doing as well as white students academically is because Latino students have weaker English language skills than white students. About half (47%) of Latinos agree.
- Compared to Latinos, whites are less likely to point to other factors such as poor performance by schools, teachers or parents to explain the performance gap.
- African Americans tend to agree with Latinos in finding multiple reasons for why Latinos are not doing as well as white students.
Higher Education
Most Latinos feel that young people starting out today have little chance of success without a college degree. Knowing this, it is not surprising that nearly all Latino parents say it is very important to them that their children go to college. (charts 12 and 13)
- Nearly all (95%) Latino parents say that it is “very” important to them that their children go to college.
- The majority (54%) of Latinos say that young people have little chance of success without a college degree. However, a sizeable portion (43%) say that young people starting out today can succeed with just a high school degree because success depends on a number of different factors.
- Native-born Latinos are more likely to say that young people need a college degree to succeed than foreign-born Latinos (60% and 51%).
Although the vast majority of white parents say that it is very important to them that their children go to college, they are less likely to feel this way than Latino and African American parents. (charts 12 and 13)
- Nearly eight in ten (78%) white parents say that it is “very” important to them that their child gets a college education. However, Latino and African American parents are even more likely to feel this way (95% and 94%).
- Although majorities of Latinos (54%) and whites (54%) say that young people have little chance of success without a college degree, African Americans are more likely to have this opinion (64%).
When asked about the reasons people do not go to college or fail to finish college, Latinos, whites and African Americans alike focused on issues involving money. However, there are contrasting views regarding other factors such as discrimination and the desirability of staying close to family. (chart 14)
- A large majority of Latinos say that the cost of tuition (77%) and the need to work and earn money (77%) are major reasons why people do not go to college or fail to finish once they have started. Whites and African Americans responded similarly on tuition (82% and 82%) and on the need to work (73% and 76%).
- A majority of Latinos (58%), whites (64%), and African Americans (71%) say that receiving a poor high school education is a major reason people do not get a college degree.
- Nearly half (48%) of Latinos say that a major reason people fail to get a college degree is because they do not feel they need one to be successful compared to 33% of whites and 35% of African Americans.
- Four in ten (40%) Latinos say that discrimination is a major reason people do not get a college degree. Latinos who were not born in the United States are more likely to feel this way than Latinos who were born in the United States (46% vs. 32%). Among African Americans 34% cite discrimination, while 13% of whites see it as a major factor in keeping people from going to college.
- Latinos (33%) are almost twice as likely as whites (17%) to say that staying close to family instead of going away to school is a major reason why people do not get a college degree (24% of African Americans say the same). Foreign-born Latinos are even more likely to say this (36%) than native-born Latinos (29%).
Language
Latinos, like nearly all Americans, agree that teaching English to the children of immigrant families is an important goal. (chart 15)
- The vast majority of Latinos (92%) say that teaching English to the children of immigrant families is a “very” important goal, and another 7% say it is a “somewhat” important goal. Whites and African Americans hold almost identical views.
- Foreign-born Latinos support this goal with greater intensity than any other group with 96% saying it is “very” important.
The vast majority of Latinos, especially the foreign born, and of African Americans think that it is important for public schools to help students from immigrant families maintain their family’s native tongue. Fewer—but still a majority—of whites support this goal. (chart 15)
- Almost nine in ten (88%) Latinos and eight in ten African Americans (79%), say that it is important for public schools to help students from immigrant families maintain their native tongue, including over two-thirds (67%) of Latinos who say that it is “very” important and another 21% who say that it is “somewhat” important.
- Foreign-born Latinos are even more likely than native-born Latinos to say it is important for schools to help kids maintain their family’s native tongue (93% vs. 81%). Among the foreign born, 74% say that it is “very” important compared to 55% of the native born.
- Fewer—but still a majority—of whites (57%), say it’s important for public schools to help kids maintain their family’s native tongue. However, four in ten (41%) whites say this goal is “not too” or “not at all important.”
Only foreign-born Latinos take a clearly positive view of how well public schools are teaching English to children who are immigrants or whose parents are immigrants. Among native-born Latinos, whites and African Americans, near majorities rate the schools as doing a “fair” or “poor” job on this score.
- Nearly three-quarters (72%) of foreign-born Latinos say the public schools are doing an “excellent” (37%) or “good” (36%) job of teaching English to children who are immigrants or whose parents are immigrants. About four in ten native-born Latinos hold similar views with 12% saying the schools are doing an “excellent” and 31% saying they are doing a “good” job.
- Half of native-born Latinos (50%) say the schools are doing a “fair” or “poor” job compared to a quarter (24%) of the foreign born.
- Among whites, about one-third say the schools are doing an “excellent” (4%) or good (30%) job of teaching English to students who are immigrants or the children of immigrants, while 47% say the schools are doing a “fair” or “poor” job.
- Four in ten African Americans say the schools are doing an “excellent” (10%) or “good” (31%) job, while 44% say the schools are doing a “fair” or “poor” job.